gno.law

Judith F. Hayes

Judge · Superior Court of San Diego County · 2007–2024

, Superior Court of California, County of San Diego 1990–1995

C++
68% — 98 of 144 rulings upheld, per qwen3.8-27b; in the top 42% of 312 graded judges

On the assumption that the model is right — qwen3.8-27b reads the court's own disposition right 70% of the time, graded on a curve: A is the top fifth of the judges graded under this model, F the bottom fifth; ++ / + / − / −− within the band. How the grade is made.

80cases reviewed on appeal
33%reversed, in whole or part, of 75 merits decisions

Outcomes on appeal

affirmed 48 reversed 19 reversed in part 6 writ granted 3 modified 2 dismissed 2

Areas

civil 78 criminal 2

By year: 2015 22 · 2016 17 · 2013 13 · 2014 10 · 2019 4 · 2021 3 · 2020 3 · 2024 2 · 2022 2 · 2018 1 · 2010 1 · 2009 1 · 2007 1 ·

Analysis

143reviewed cases analysed
513rulings read
3rulings where the model disagrees with the court
27cases with a verified missed authority
2appellate opinions called questionable

Counts of a model's readings across this judge's reviewed cases, each shown on its case page beside the court's disposition. Not a finding about the judge.

Cases

  1. McHugh v. Protective Life Insurance CA4/1 D072863 · 2022-10-10 · civil · reversed
  2. Citizens for Responsible etc. v. Department of Transportation D074374 · 2020-03-24 · civil · reversed
  3. Cleveland Nat. Forest Foundation v. County of San Diego D073744M · 2019-08-21 · civil · reversed
  4. Cleveland Nat. Forest Foundation v. County of San Diego D073744 · 2019-07-25 · civil · reversed
  5. Dogan v. Comanche Hills Apartments D072328 · 2019-01-22 · civil · reversed
  6. Hays v. Covenant Care La Jolla CA4/1 D068249 · 2016-08-12 · civil · reversed
  7. Williams v. Nordstrom, Inc. CA4/1 D069051 · 2016-07-15 · civil · reversed
  8. Patton v. Martins CA4/1 D067214 · 2016-05-04 · civil · reversed
  9. Samarkos v. Goddard CA4/1 D066284 · 2015-10-28 · civil · reversed
  10. Samarkos v. Goddard CA4/1 D067533 · 2015-10-28 · civil · reversed
  11. Save Desert Rose v. City of Encinitas CA4/1 D066218 · 2015-10-28 · civil · reversed
  12. Bayasi v. Cerullo CA4/1 D065970 · 2015-08-25 · civil · reversed
  13. Zucchet v. Galardi D064104 · 2014-09-25 · civil · reversed
  14. Save Our Heritage Organisation v. County of San Diego CA4/1 D064006 · 2014-07-22 · criminal · reversed
  15. Huffman v. California CA4/1 D063025 · 2013-11-12 · civil · reversed
  16. McMillin Mgt. Services v. State Farm Gen. Ins. CA4/1 D062178 · 2013-09-20 · civil · reversed
  17. Panesar v. Panesar CA4/1 D060842 · 2013-08-09 · civil · reversed
  18. Silver Creek, LLC v. BlackRock Realty Advisors, Inc. D052587 · 2009-05-20 · civil · reversed
  19. Patel v. LIEBERMENSCH D048582 · 2007-08-21 · civil · reversed