gno.law

E. P. Shortall

Judge · Superior Court of City and County of San Francisco · 1910–1935

180cases reviewed on appeal
30%reversed, in whole or part, of 168 merits decisions

Outcomes on appeal

affirmed 114 reversed 44 other 11 reversed in part 6 modified 4 dismissed 1

Areas

civil 171 probate 6 family 2 criminal 1

By year: 1923 18 · 1919 18 · 1928 17 · 1927 16 · 1930 12 · 1929 11 · 1918 11 · 1931 10 · 1922 10 · 1921 9 · 1924 8 · 1917 8 · 1933 6 · 1932 6 · 1925 5 · 1920 5 · 1926 3 · 1916 3 · 1934 2 · 1935 1 · 1910 1 ·

Analysis

No analyses yet. When they exist, this shows counts of the model's findings across this judge's reviewed cases — with the court's own dispositions beside them, and only from 10 cases.

Cases reviewed on appeal (every role)

  1. Niles Sand, Gravel & Rock Co. v. Muir Civ. No. 4027. · 1921-12-06 · civil · affirmed
  2. Allred v. Sheehan Civ. No. 3906. · 1921-10-28 · civil · reversed
  3. San Francisco Lumber Co. v. Yates Civ. No. 3929. · 1921-08-30 · civil · reversed
  4. Schuyler v. Pantages Civ. No. 3860. · 1921-08-24 · civil · reversed
  5. Norris v. Campbell Electric Corp. Civ. No. 3878. · 1921-08-23 · civil · reversed in part
  6. Marks v. Jos. H. Rucker & Co. Civ. No. 3794. · 1921-07-16 · civil · reversed
  7. H. Hackfeld Co., Ltd. v. Castle S. F. No. 8884. · 1921-06-06 · civil · affirmed
  8. Wright & Kimbrough v. Dewees Civ. No. 3569. · 1921-03-23 · civil · reversed
  9. California National Supply Co. (A Corporation) v. O'Brien Civ. No. 3240. · 1921-03-01 · civil · reversed in part
  10. Niles Sand & Rock Co. v. Muir Civ. No. 3604. · 1920-12-27 · civil · modified
  11. Lafargue v. United Railroad of San Francisco S. F. No. 8732. · 1920-09-21 · civil · affirmed
  12. Gaschlin v. Sierra Civ. No. 3322. · 1920-06-03 · civil · affirmed
  13. Schwarz v. Bohle Civ. No. 3328. · 1920-05-11 · civil · affirmed
  14. Bertola v. Allred Civ. No. 3282. · 1920-03-17 · civil · affirmed
  15. Scherer v. Eidenmuller Civ. No. 2898. · 1919-12-31 · civil · reversed
  16. Percival v. National Drama Corporation L. A. No. 5214. · 1919-12-05 · civil · reversed
  17. California Canneries Co. v. Great Western Lumber Co. Civ. No. 2933. · 1919-11-03 · civil · affirmed
  18. Great Western Lumber Co. v. Calif. Canneries Co. Civ. No. 2932. · 1919-11-03 · civil · affirmed
  19. Anderson v. Aronsohn S. F. No. 8581. · 1919-09-26 · civil · reversed
  20. Berger v. Bright L. A. No. 5248. · 1919-08-26 · civil · affirmed
  21. Mathews v. Savings Union Bank & Trust Co. Civ. No. 2807. · 1919-08-26 · civil · reversed
  22. Michalek v. New Almaden Co., Inc. Civ. No. 2893. · 1919-08-18 · civil · reversed
  23. Pacific Western Commercial Co. v. Western Wholesale Drug Co. Civ. No. 2774. · 1919-06-23 · civil · affirmed
  24. Stanford Hotel Co. v. M. Schwind Co. S. F. No. 8250. · 1919-05-09 · civil · affirmed
  25. Head v. Solomon Civ. No. 2764. · 1919-04-29 · civil · affirmed