Judges
Who sits in which San Diego department
Letters are by qwen3.8-27b — it reads the court's own disposition right 70% of the time (how that is measured); pick another model above to compare, on the assumption that the model is right.
10,950 judges · a reversal rate is shown from 10 merits decisions in this corpus
| Name | Grade | Role | Where | Cases | Years | Reversed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jorge C. Hernandez | A++ | Judge | Riverside County | 16 | 2013–2026 | 33% of 15 |
| David J. Hesseltine | Judge | Orange County | 16 | 2023–2026 | 62% of 13 | |
| William H. Hunt | A- | Justice, Court of Appeal | ca9 | 16 | 1910–1956 | — |
| Nathan D. Ide | Judge | Tulare County | 16 | 2016–2025 | 38% of 16 | |
| William F. James | Judge | Santa Clara County | 16 | 1934–1964 | 27% of 15 | |
| Stephanie L. Jamieson | Judge | calsuperct | 16 | 2024–2026 | 14% of 14 | |
| Jon N. Kapetan | Judge | Fresno County | 16 | 2013–2024 | 17% of 12 | |
| Abraham Khan | Judge | calsuperct | 16 | 2008–2015 | 36% of 14 | |
| Ronald P. Kreber | Judge | Orange County | 16 | 2004–2016 | 33% of 15 | |
| James R. Lambden | Judge | Alameda County | 16 | 1992–1996 | 30% of 10 | |
| J. M. Mannon | Judge | Mendocino County | 16 | 1900–1906 | 42% of 12 | |
| William F. McDonald | Judge | Orange County | 16 | 1989–2007 | — | |
| McNUTT | Justice, Court of Appeal | Court of Appeal | 16 | 1933–1937 | — | |
| Henry A. Melvin | Judge | Alameda County | 16 | 1904–1910 | 20% of 10 | |
| Russell L. Moore | A++ | Judge | Riverside County | 16 | 2020–2024 | 31% of 13 |
| John Murphy | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 2013–2016 | 31% of 16 | |
| Leland C. Nielsen | Judge | San Diego County | 16 | 1972–1998 | 18% of 11 | |
| Kathleen Parker | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 1967–1986 | 31% of 16 | |
| Charles S. Peery | Judge | City and County of San Francisco | 16 | 1959–1981 | 40% of 15 | |
| Pinch | Justice, Court of Appeal | Court of Appeal | 16 | 1923–1930 | — | |
| Oval Pirkey | Judge | Glenn County | 16 | 1901–1907 | — | |
| Poliak | Justice, Court of Appeal | Court of Appeal | 16 | 2008–2017 | — | |
| Robert E. Roberts | Judge | El Dorado County | 16 | 1958–1975 | 57% of 14 | |
| Raymond R. Roberts | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 1968–1989 | 70% of 10 | |
| Ronald B. Robie | Judge | Sacramento County | 16 | 1990–2003 | 18% of 11 | |
| Hugh Rose III | Judge | Stanislaus County | 16 | 1982–2000 | 40% of 10 | |
| Ronald H. Rose | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 2013–2016 | 6% of 16 | |
| R. C. Rust | Judge | Amador County | 16 | 1899–1911 | — | |
| Yvonne T. Sanchez | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 2013–2021 | 31% of 16 | |
| Milton D. Sapiro | Judge | City and County of San Francisco | 16 | 1951–1960 | 12% of 16 | |
| Leon Savitch | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 1981–1992 | 18% of 11 | |
| Jeanne Schechter | — | Temporary judge | Merced County | 16 | 2020–2023 | 36% of 14 |
| Harold W. Schweitzer | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 1951–1967 | 25% of 16 | |
| H. S. Shaffer | Judge | Merced Cunty County | 16 | 1932–1949 | 7% of 15 | |
| Norm Shapiro | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 2014–2025 | 13% of 15 | |
| John Shea | Judge | Orange County | 16 | 1955–1984 | 13% of 15 | |
| Charles A. Shurtleff | Justice, Court of Appeal | Supreme Court | 16 | 1921–1922 | — | |
| Lily L. Sinfield | Judge | San Bernardino County | 16 | 2014–2016 | 8% of 12 | |
| Singleton | Justice, Court of Appeal | ca9 | 16 | 2009–2016 | — | |
| Salvatore Sirna | Judge | calsuperct | 16 | 2013–2025 | 21% of 14 | |
| Otto R. Skopil, Jr. | Justice, Court of Appeal | ca9 | 16 | 1980–2011 | — | |
| Charles W. Slack | Judge | City and County of San Francisco | 16 | 1900–1905 | — | |
| Julie A. Swain | Judge | Orange County | 16 | 2023–2026 | 44% of 16 | |
| David M. Szumowski | F | Judge | San Diego County | 16 | 2002–2016 | 19% of 16 |
| Fred A. Treat | Judge | Monterey County | 16 | 1925–1930 | 38% of 16 | |
| Howard B. Turrentine | Judge | San Diego County | 16 | 1969–1998 | 15% of 13 | |
| Vickers | Justice, Court of Appeal | Court of Appeal | 16 | 1942–1952 | — | |
| William G. Watson, Jr. | Judge | Humboldt County | 16 | 1958–1979 | 57% of 14 | |
| Allen J. Webster | Judge | Los Angeles County | 16 | 2006–2024 | 12% of 16 | |
| Joseph B. Widman | F++ | Judge | San Bernardino County | 16 | 2023–2026 | 25% of 12 |