In re Ridgecrest Development Co.
In the Matter of RIDGECREST DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, Bankrupt
- Proceeding
- district
- Area
- other
- Panel
- Hall (author)
Analysis
The court reviewed a Referee's order that allowed a federal tax claim but disallowed post-petition interest on the portion of the claim secured by pre-bankruptcy liens. The court reversed the Referee's order, holding that the federal tax liens secured the interest accruing after the bankruptcy filing, and ordered that the claim bear 6% interest until paid.
| What the court decided | The model |
|---|---|
Reversal of the Referee's order disallowing post-petition interest on secured federal tax claims“That the Order of the Referee dated December 12, 1949, be and the same is hereby reversed, and that. the. Federal tax claim secured by lien shall bear interest at 6% per annum, as provided by law, accruing subsequent to the date of the filing of the petition in bankruptcy until the claim is paid.” | agree with court The court correctly applied the principle that federal tax liens, once perfected, secure not only the principal tax debt but also the interest accruing thereon. Because the liens were perfected prior to the bankruptcy petition, the trustee took the estate subject to these liens, which continued to secure the interest accruing after the filing. The Referee's error was in treating the post-petition interest as unsecured or disallowable despite the existence of the perfected lien. |
The order itself: sound — The order is procedurally sound in its application of the specific statutory provisions governing federal tax liens. It correctly identifies that the liens were perfected pre-petition and therefore continue to secure the debt, including post-petition interest. The reasoning is concise but directly addresses the legal error in the Referee's decision.
Opinion — Hall
HALL, District Judge.
The Referee’s Certificate on Review and briefs of counsel having been filed, and the Court having considered such Certificate, briefs, and the Referee’s Opinion, the Court hereby makes the following :
Findings of Fact I. That Ridgecrest Development Company, a corporation, Kern County, California, pursuant to a resolution passed by its board of directors, filed its voluntary petition in bankruptcy and was adjudged bankrupt on May 12, 1947.
II. That on June 6, 1947, the first meeting of creditors was held, and Paul W. Sampsell was elected trustee in bankruptcy, and at all times since that date has been in possession of the assets of the bankrupt corporation.
III. That on November 14, 1947, a claim for Federal taxes due and owing by the bankrupt was filed in this proceeding by the Collector of Internal Revenue for the Sixth Collection District of California, covering Federal Insurance contributions, unemployment, withholding and admissions taxes in the principal sum of $14,728.44, together with assessed penalty of $761.97, assessed interest $139.14, delinquency penalty of $698.71, and accrued interest of $793.66, computed to November 30, 1947, or $2.55 per day until payment.
IV. That except for three items, totaling $1,680.81, the entire claim of the Collector of Internal Revenue was secured by liens which arose and were recorded in the office of the County Recorder, Kern County, California, prior to the date on which the bankrupt corporation filed its petition in bankruptcy.
V. That by an order dated December 12, 1949, the Referee in Bankruptcy, William A. McGugin, allowed the claim of the Collector of Internal Revenue in the amount claimed for taxes, penalties, and interest accruing prior to thé date the bankrupt corporation filed its petition in bankruptcy but disallowed and rejected the claim of the Collector of Internal Revenue for interest accruing from the date of the filing of the petition in bankruptcy to the date of payment of said claim on those items secured by liens which arose and were recorded pri- or to bankruptcy.
From the foregoing the Court makes the following:
Conclusions of Law I. That by virtue of Sections 3670-3672 of the Internal Revenue Code, 26 U.S.C.A. §§ 3670-3672, the liens of the United States attached to all property, whether real or personal, of the bankrupt corporation.
II. That the liens of the United States upon all the property of the bankrupt corporation are security not only for the principal tax obligations of the bankrupt, but for the interest accruing thereon as a part of the tax obligation.
III. That the entire estate of the bankrupt corporation came into the *710hands of the duly appointed trustee in bankruptcy charged with the liens of the United States.
IV. That Federal tax claims secured by liens perfected before bankruptcy bear interest as provided by law after the date the petition in bankruptcy is filed and until payment.
Now, Therefore, It Is Hereby Ordered: That the Order of the Referee dated December 12, 1949, be and the same is hereby reversed, and that. the. Federal tax claim secured by lien shall bear interest at 6% per annum, as provided by law, accruing subsequent to the date of the filing of the petition in bankruptcy until the claim is paid.
Cited by
- In re Pollard Bros. No. 7069 · 1955-01-14