gno.law

Pines v. Blair

California Court of Appeal · Civ. No. 20232 · 1954-08-17 · Published · 127 Cal. App. 2d 130 · 273 P.2d 349 · 1954 Cal. App. LEXIS 1311

Estate of SUSAN ANN BLAIR, HARRY A. PINES v. ALFRED GRANVILLE BLAIR

Area
civil
Panel
Louis C. Drapeau (author)

Analysis

No analysis yet. When one exists it is a model's reading of this opinion — the rulings it reviewed, whether it agrees with the court, and the authorities it checked — shown beside the court's own disposition, never in place of it. How analyses are made.

Opinion — Drapeau

DRAPEAU, J.

Among the items in this estate were an apartment house and parking lot in Pasadena, across the street from the Pasadena city hall. The property was appraised in the probate estate for $106,000. It had been appraised for $145,000 in the guardianship estate of decedent.

The county of Los Angeles became interested in the parking *131lot. Later on the county decided to acquire both parcels. Neither the county nor the estate could agree upon the value. It was therefore necessary for counsel for the estate to prepare for trial a defendant’s case in eminent domain. Finally the county offered $157,500, which was accepted by the estate and approved by the probate court.

Counsel petitioned for extraordinary fees, objections were made, the matter was heard by the court, and an order made allowing counsel $10,000. From this order interested parties in the estate appeal. (See Estate of Blair, 126 Cal.App.2d 759 [272 P.2d 866].)

The probate court had before it evidence that supports the order. One of counsel testified to time spent in protracted negotiations, in familiarizing himself with values, preparing the legal case, and directing preparation for the presentation of the facts to a trial court.

It is only when there is a manifest abuse of discretion that a reviewing court will overrule such orders as this. (Estate of Lundell, 95 Cal.App.2d 352 [212 P.2d 914, 214 P.2d 23].)

The order is affirmed.

Doran, Acting P. J., and Mosk, J. pro tern.,* concurred.

Assigned by Chairman of Judicial Council.

Cites, in this corpus

Cited by