Estate of Cheda
In the Matter of the Estate of SILVIS H. CHEDA, Deceased. GEORGE A. CHEDA, Etc., Appellant, v. ELENORE A. CHEDA, Respondent
- Area
- probate
- Panel
- The Court (author)
Analysis
No analysis yet. When one exists it is a model's reading of this opinion — the rulings it reviewed, whether it agrees with the court, and the authorities it checked — shown beside the court's own disposition, never in place of it. How analyses are made.
Opinion
THE COURT.
Motion to dismiss appeal from order on ground that the same is not an appealable order.
The order was one made by the superior court under section 1597 et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure, directing the executors to transfer and deliver to a third party certain assets of the estate, being certain shares of bank stock. The application for the order and the order were based on a contract for the sale thereof alleged to have been made by the deceased.
[1]
The claim that the order is nonappealable is based on the fact that such an order is not specified as an appeal-able order in the statute specifying the probate judgments and orders from which an appeal may be taken. (Code Civ.
*323 Proc., subd. 3, sec. 963.) If the order here were exclusively a probate order there would be much force in the claim.
[2]
We are of opinion, however, that the proceeding authorized by section 1597 et seq. is in substance more than, this, being practically a proceeding in equity terminating in a final judgment, having the full force and effect of a final judgment in an action for specific performance of a contract. As such we deem the order made therein a final judgment, appealable under subdivision 1 of section 963 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
It was for this reason that the motion to dismiss the appeal was denied from the bench.
Angellotti, C. J., Wilbur, J., Shaw, J., Sloane, J;, Shurtleff, J., Lawlor, J., and Lennon, J., concurred.
Cited by
- Estate of Jacobson v. Trinz Civ. 13745 · 1942-12-19
- In Re Estate of Backesto Civ. No. 4540. · 1923-07-27
- In Re Proceeding to Validate Sutter-Butte By-Pass Assessment Number Six Sac. No. 3405. · 1923-03-06
- Estate of Cheda Civ. No. 4277. · 1922-07-03